How to Sign a Lease for Jointly Owned Property in Hong Kong?

In the Hong Kong rental market, the process of signing a lease between tenants and landlords is crucial, especially when the property is owned by multiple landlords. The forms of joint property ownership in Hong Kong are primarily classified into "Joint Tenancy" and "Tenancy in Common," which fundamentally differ in terms of inheritance rights and the signing of rental agreements. Understanding these differences is vital for tenants to ensure the validity of the lease and protect their rights.

What is Joint Tenancy?

Legally, Joint Tenancy refers to a form of ownership where all owners possess undivided and collective rights to the property, along with the principle of the right of survivorship . In this form of ownership, if one of the owners passes away, their share automatically transfers to the remaining co-owners, rather than being distributed according to a will or the laws of intestacy. This automatic transfer characteristic is the most significant feature of Survivorship.

What is Tenancy in Common?

Tenancy in Common allows the property to be divided among owners in specific proportions. Each owner has independent control over their share, and upon the owner's death, their share is inherited according to their will or legal stipulations, contrasting sharply with Survivorship.

Joint Tenancy vs.Tenancy in Common: Main Differences

The primary difference between Joint Tenancy and Tenancy in Common lies in the methods of inheritance and property control. In Joint Tenancy, there is a closer connection between owners, as the death of any party results in their share automatically passing to the remaining owners. Tenancy in Common, however, offers more individual control, allowing each owner's share to be independently inherited or sold.

What is Severance of Joint Tenancy in Hong Kong

Severance of joint tenancy in Hong Kong is a legal process that ends the unified ownership characteristic of joint tenancy, transforming it into a tenancy in common. This action is significant because, in a joint tenancy, all co-owners have equal rights to the entire property with a right of survivorship—meaning when one joint tenant dies, their share automatically transfers to the surviving joint tenants.

Upon severance, the property ownership shifts to a tenancy in common where each owner holds a distinct, divisible share without the right of survivorship. This allows an owner's share to be distributed according to their will or intestacy laws upon death, rather than passing directly to the other co-owners.

4 Ways to sever a joint tenancy include:

• Sale or Transfer: Selling or transferring their share by a joint tenant severs their portion, creating a tenancy in common for that share.
• Mutual Agreement: All co-owners agree to convert the joint tenancy into a tenancy in common.
• Partition: Seeking a court order to divide or sell the property, distributing the proceeds among the co-owners.
• Unilateral Action: A joint tenant may independently act to sever by altering their property interest, such as by a deed to themselves.

Survivorship Property Rights and Leases

Under Survivorship, the property is jointly owned by two or more owners in an indivisible manner. This means that upon the death of one owner, their ownership automatically transfers to the surviving owners, instead of being inherited according to a will or the laws of intestacy. Therefore, theoretically, the signature of one owner could represent all owners in signing a lease, provided that the signing owner has the consent of the others. However, to avoid potential disputes, it is recommended that all owners sign the lease together, or at least have a clear written authorization.

Tenancy in Common Property Rights and Leases

Unlike Survivorship, Tenancy in Common allows the property to be co-owned by multiple people, with each owner having independent rights to their share. In this case, if one of the owners dies, their share is dealt with according to a will or the laws of inheritance, rather than automatically transferring to the other owners. Thus, the signing of the lease requires the joint signatures of all owners (or their legal representatives) to ensure the lease's legal validity and the protection of the tenant's rights.

Disputes in Joint Tenancy Leases

To better understand potential disputes in Joint Tenancy leases, let's consider a specific example:

For instance, if the husband signs the lease without informing the wife, and the wife later demands the lease be terminated or claims it was signed without her consent, this could place the tenant in a difficult position amidst the owners' dispute. In such cases, the lease might be considered invalid for not having the consent of all owners, forcing the tenant to unexpectedly look for a new place.

This example highlights that even under Survivorship, the best practice to protect all parties' interests is for all owners to jointly sign the lease or provide clear written consent. It also reminds tenants to verify the property's ownership form and all owners' consent before signing to avoid potential rental disputes in the future.

Signing a Lease for Jointly Owned Property

When signing a lease, tenants must clarify the ownership situation, with the following three points being particularly important:

1. Verify the Property Ownership Form: Before signing, tenants should inquire and confirm the property's ownership form (Survivorship or Tenancy in Common) to understand which owners' consent or signatures are needed.
2. Request to See the Power of Attorney: If the property is being signed on behalf of other owners by one owner, tenants should ask to see the Power of Attorney to confirm its legality.
3. Communicate with All Owners: If possible, tenants should try to communicate with all owners to confirm their consent to the lease to prevent any future disputes.

LetsGetHome: Helping You Get A Better Home in HK

Whether it's Survivorship or Tenancy in Common, ensuring the consent and signatures of all owners is crucial to secure the lease's validity and avoid potential disputes in the future.

LetsGetHome is Hong Kong's only pay-as-you-go real estate platform, focusing on rental services and providing transparent, fair, and convenient agency services for landlords and tenants. Sign up LetsGetHome now, you can enjoy free property viewing, negotiation, and signing, significantly saving on rental costs.